Gatsby shoes

Reviews and ratings: 35 %

Gatsby shoes review.

Description Gatsby shoes

Gatsby Shoes, as inferred from various online reviews and descriptions, seems to be a brand that offers a range of footwear. Here’s a more detailed description based on the available information:

  • Style and Design: Gatsby Shoes appears to offer a variety of styles, including classic loafers, trendy sneakers, elegant heels, and comfortable flats. Their designs are described as versatile, suitable for both formal and casual settings, and catering to a diverse customer base.
  • Product Quality: The quality of Gatsby Shoes is a point of contention among customers. While some reviews suggest the use of durable materials like leather, canvas, and rubber, there are numerous complaints about the shoes being of poor quality, with some described as “fake and plastic.”
  • Fit and Comfort: There are mixed opinions regarding the fit and comfort of the shoes. Some customers find them suitable, while others report issues with incorrect sizing and lack of comfort.
  • Customer Service: The brand’s customer service is heavily criticized in several reviews. Customers often report difficulties in contacting the company, unresolved issues, and overall dissatisfaction with the service provided.
  • Shipping and Delivery: Gatsby Shoes has faced criticism for slow shipping and delivery processes. Customers have reported extended delays, issues with order processing, and receiving incorrect or damaged items.
  • Return and Refund Policies: The return and refund processes of Gatsby Shoes are often described as complicated and unsatisfactory. Customers have expressed frustration over misleading and deceptive policies.
  • Price and Value Proposition: While specific pricing details are not consistently mentioned, the brand is sometimes positioned as a premium option. However, the value proposition is questioned due to the reported issues with quality and service.
  • Legitimacy and Trustworthiness: There are concerns about the legitimacy and transparency of the brand. Low trust scores on various websites and accusations of deceptive practices contribute to these concerns.

Overall, Gatsby Shoes presents a mixed image. While there are mentions of stylish designs and a variety of options, the brand seems to struggle with quality consistency, customer service, and overall customer satisfaction.

Illustrative image for the reviewed product Gatsby shoes. Source: Dall-E.

Illustrative image for the reviewed product Gatsby shoes. Source: Dall-E.

In connection with Gatsby shoes reviews, people most often search for the following phrases:

  • gatsby shoes review
  • gatsby shoes reviews

Last review update: 5. 1. 2024

Main advantages

  • Value for Money: Positive reviews often mention that the shoes are good value for money.
  • Versatile Design: The shoes are praised for their aesthetic versatility, suitable for both formal and casual settings.

Main disadvantages

  • Slow and Problematic Shipping: Customers frequently reported extended shipping and delivery times, often experiencing delays and receiving incorrect or damaged items.
  • Poor Product Quality: Many reviews mentioned shoes falling apart, being of inferior quality, or not matching the advertised images.
  • Ineffective Customer Service: Common complaints included difficulty in communication, unresponsive customer support, and overall poor service experience.
  • Complicated Returns and Refunds: The return and refund processes were often described as complicated, misleading, and unsatisfactory, causing frustration among customers.
  • Concerns About Business Legitimacy: Accusations and concerns about the company being a scam, with deceptive policies and a lack of transparency in business practices.
  • Negative Online Ratings and Trust Issues: The brand received low ratings and trust scores across various review platforms, indicating a high level of customer dissatisfaction and trust issues.

Expert reviews

55 %

Gatsbyshoes Reviews from

Based on the reviews provided, the e-shop seems to have a mixed reputation. Here’s a summary of the content:

Positive Aspects:

  • Some customers are satisfied with their purchases, praising the comfort, style, and fit of the shoes.
  • Positive reviews often mention the shoes being good value for money and suitable for various occasions.
  • A few customers appreciated the customer service, especially in handling returns and exchanges.

Negative Aspects:

  • Numerous customers reported issues with slow shipping and delivery times, often taking several weeks.
  • There are complaints about poor quality, with some shoes falling apart or not matching the advertised images.
  • Several reviews mention a lack of effective customer service, with difficulties in communication and resolving issues.
  • Some customers experienced problems with returns and refunds, describing the process as complicated and unsatisfactory.
  • There are concerns about the company’s business practices, with accusations of it being a scam or using deceptive policies.

Final Score: Considering the mixed nature of the reviews, with a significant number of both positive and negative experiences, the e-shop could be rated around 55% on a scale from 0% to 100%. This score reflects the balance between the high satisfaction of some customers and the serious issues and dissatisfaction reported by others.

Read all reviews…

Gatsbyshoes Reviews[online]. [cited 05. 01. 2024]. Available from:


20 %

Gatsbyshoes reviews from

Based on the information provided, Gatsbyshoes LLC has a pattern of complaints that include:

  • Misleading and/or Deceptive Refund Policy: Customers have reported issues with the company’s refund policy, where promises of “full refunds” were not honored.
  • Sub-Optimal Customer Service: There are numerous complaints about poor customer service, including lack of response to emails and issues with phone support.
  • Inferior Fit and Quality: Customers have expressed dissatisfaction with the fit and quality of the products.
  • Issues with Order Processing and Delivery: There are multiple complaints regarding delivery issues, such as delays, tracking problems, and receiving incorrect or damaged items.
  • Problems with Product Returns and Exchanges: Customers have faced difficulties in returning or exchanging products, with complaints about the company’s return process being complicated and unresponsive.
  • Lack of Transparency and Communication: The company has been criticized for not being transparent about its policies and for failing to communicate effectively with customers.

Given these issues, particularly the pattern of complaints about misleading policies, poor customer service, and product quality concerns, Gatsbyshoes LLC would likely receive a low score. On a scale from 0% to 100%, where 0% is the worst and 100% is the best, Gatsbyshoes LLC could be rated around 20%. This score reflects the significant number of unresolved complaints and the nature of the issues reported by customers.

Read all reviews…

Gatsbyshoes LLC | Complaints | Better Business Bureau® Profile [online]. [cited 2024 Jan 05]. Available from:
20 %

Is Legit? from

Based on the review from Scam Detector, has several issues that raise concerns about its legitimacy and trustworthiness:

  • Low Trust Score: The Scam Detector’s algorithm gives a low trust rank of 29.0/100, indicating the site is risky and dubious.
  • New Domain with Hidden WHOIS Data: The domain is relatively new, registered in August 2020, and the WHOIS data is hidden, which can be a red flag for a lack of transparency.
  • Proximity to Suspicious Websites: The site has a proximity score of 15/100 to suspicious websites, which could indicate potential risks.
  • Threat, Phishing, Malware, and Spam Scores: The site has low but non-zero scores in these categories, suggesting some level of risk.
  • Customer Complaints and Feedback: There are numerous customer complaints about issues such as poor quality products, lack of customer service, difficulty in returning products, and deceptive practices.
  • Lack of Transparency and Communication: The company’s lack of transparency about its location and the unavailability of effective customer support are concerning.

Given these factors, on a scale from 0% to 100%, where 0% is the worst and 100% is the best, would likely receive a score around 20%. This low score reflects the significant concerns about the site’s legitimacy, customer service issues, and overall trustworthiness.

Read all reviews…

Is Legit?[online]. [cited 05. 01. 2024]. Available from:
10 %

Gatsby Shoes reviews from

Based on the reviews and information provided, Gatsby Shoes appears to have a significantly negative reputation. Here’s a summary of the key points:

  • Overall Rating: Gatsby Shoes has a very low rating of 1.2 out of 5 based on 21 reviews.
  • Product Quality: The quality of the products is rated poorly at 1.6 out of 16, indicating widespread dissatisfaction with the quality of the shoes.
  • Return and Shipping Issues: Many customers reported problems with returns and shipping. The return process is described as complicated and costly, with a rating of 2.1 out of 14 for shipping.
  • Sizing and Appearance: There are mixed reviews about sizing, with some finding the shoes too small or too large. The product appearance received mixed feedback, with some customers stating the products were not as advertised.
  • Customer Service: The company’s customer service is heavily criticized. Many customers reported difficulty in contacting the company and resolving issues.

Negative Customer Experiences: Numerous customers expressed strong dissatisfaction, citing issues such as poor quality, misleading advertising, difficult return processes, and unresponsive customer service.

Positive Reviews: There are very few positive reviews, with only about 5% of the reviews being positive.

Given these factors, on a scale from 0% to 100%, Gatsby Shoes would likely receive a score around 10%. This score reflects the overwhelmingly negative customer experiences and issues with product quality, shipping, returns, and customer service.

Read all reviews…

Gatsby Shoes reviews [online]. [cited 05. 01. 2024]. Available from:
80 %

Gatsby shoe review: are Gatsby shoes worth it?

Based on the review by Hope, Gatsby Shoes presents itself as a brand offering a diverse range of stylish and high-quality footwear for both men and women. The review covers various aspects of the brand, including style, quality, customer service, shipping, pricing, and overall value proposition. Here’s a brief summary:

  • Classic Loafers: Described as timeless and versatile, perfect for both casual and formal wear.
  • Trendy Sneakers: Highlighted for their style, comfort, and versatility, suitable for everyday wear.
  • Elegant Heels: Ideal for dressy occasions, available in various styles and colors.
  • Comfortable Flats: Praised for their practicality and versatility, suitable for everyday activities.
  • Material Quality: The shoes are made from durable materials like leather, canvas, and rubber, with some eco-friendly options.
  • Sizing and Fit: Emphasizes the importance of finding the right size and fit for comfort.
  • Customer Service: Positive experiences reported with responsive and helpful customer service.
  • Shipping and Delivery: Efficient and timely, with options for tracking and expedited delivery.
  • Price and Value: Positioned as a premium brand, with prices higher than some competitors but justified by quality and design.

Given this comprehensive analysis, Gatsby Shoes would likely score high on a scale of 0% to 100%. The brand seems to excel in quality, style, and customer service, though the pricing is on the higher side. Balancing these factors, Gatsby Shoes could be rated around 80%, reflecting its strong points in quality and design, with the only significant drawback being its premium pricing.

Read all reviews…

Gatsby shoe review: are Gatsby shoes worth it? - [online]. [cited 05. 01. 2024]. Available from:
20 %

Gatsby Shoes Review 2023 from

The review of Gatsby Shoes in 2023 provides a detailed analysis of the brand, focusing on various aspects such as design, quality, customer service, and legitimacy. Here’s a brief summary along with a final score:

  • Introduction: Gatsby Shoes is known for its simple and smart designs, catering to men in the United States. The review aims to provide an unbiased perspective amidst mixed online reviews.
  • Manufacturing: The exact manufacturing location of Gatsby Shoes is unclear, with suggestions of production in China and claims of handcrafting in Italy.
  • Design and Aesthetics: The shoes are praised for their aesthetic versatility, suitable for both formal and casual settings.
  • Quality and Comfort: There are significant concerns about the quality, with reports of the shoes being “fake and plastic,” having sizing issues, and lacking comfort.

Pros and Cons:

  • Pros: Stylish design, variety, orthopedic benefits, and affordable pricing.
  • Cons: Issues with fit, material quality, delivery delays, and customer service.

Legitimacy Concerns: The review raises questions about the legitimacy of Gatsby Shoes, citing a lack of transparency in business practices and owner information.

Customer Reviews: Mixed reviews with some customers reporting poor quality, incorrect sizing, and inadequate customer service.

  • Website Analysis: The website has a low domain authority and is rated as potentially risky and dubious with a score of 29.00 by the Scam Detector’s website validator.
  • Return and Refund Policy: The policy exists but is described as misleading and deceptive.
  • Delivery and Shipping: Delivery takes 10 to 30 business days, but there are reports of delays.
  • Conclusion: The review concludes that Gatsby Shoes, while offering stylish designs, has significant issues with quality, sizing, and potentially deceptive business practices, suggesting it might be a scam.

Based on this review, Gatsby Shoes would receive a low score on a scale of 0% to 100%. Considering the concerns about quality, legitimacy, and customer satisfaction, the score would likely be around 20% to 30%, reflecting the serious issues highlighted in the review.

Read all reviews…

Gatsby Shoes Review 2023 | Is Gatsby really FAKE or NOT? [online]. [cited 05. 01. 2024]. Available from:

Expert video reviews

Gatsby Shoe review - Man I wanted to like this shoe 👟 - YouTube [online]. [cited 05. 01. 2024]. Available from:

The truth about the new Gatsby 👟 shoes - YouTube [online]. [cited 2024 Jan 05]. Available from:

User ratings and reviews

Rated 0.0 out of 5
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.